A while back, I saw the movie Waitress, starring Keri Russell and Nathan Fillion. I enjoyed it a lot and kept thinking of the little song Jenna would sing throughout the movie.
What do these two statements have in common? Well, in 2016, Waitress became a Broadway musical, with the music and lyrics written by Sara Bareilles, who even played Jenna on stage for a while.
And this past weekend, I finally got to see it during its tour at The National Theatre in Washington, DC.
This is what the curtain looks like before the show and during intermission. Makes you hungry for pie, right? (They actually were selling jars of it in the lobby, but we didn't get any.)
In the beginning, the curtain opens up to what is supposed to be the kitchen of Joe's Diner, where Jenna is baking her pies with the interesting names. Then the stage quickly reverts to the diner and it looks amazing. The backdrop sets the scene, making us feel like the diner is in the middle of a country road. I was completely impressed with the sets for this production, between the diner, Jenna's house, and the doctor's office. It all had a realistic feel. The orchestra was on stage for most of the show and they interacted with the cast, as well as dressed to fit the mood of the scene.
![]() |
| From Broadway.com |
The music was great. I could easily tell that Sara Bareilles had written it, as the songs carried her flair throughout. Some of the songs that stood out for me were "Opening Up," "What Baking Can Do," "When He Sees Me," "You Will Still Be Mine," "Never Ever Getting Rid of Me," "Bad Idea," "I Didn't Plan It," "She Used to Be Mine," and "Everything Changes." I didn't know that many of the songs going in, and I wouldn't say I was singing them coming out, but I am excited to listen to the soundtrack more, as it will take me back to the experience of watching it. Perhaps even more songs will stand out to me by then. The original soundtrack features the voices of Keala Settle (Lettie in The Greatest Showman) as Becky and Kimiko Glenn (Soso in Orange is the New Black) as Dawn.
I didn't recognize anyone from the touring cast, but I thought they were a terrific ensemble. I enjoyed watching them together and not knowing them to begin with kept them in character more than if I were thinking of them as someone famous. (Like when I saw Adam Pascal as Shakespeare in Something Rotten.) Desi Oakley was fantastic as Jenna. She really owned that part and had an incredible singing voice. At first, I was annoyed with her speaking voice. It was this low southern accent. However, I remembered that Keri Russell did that with her voice in the movie (perhaps more subtly) and it endeared me to Desi after I got used to it. Lenne Klingaman and Charity Angel Dawson were perfect in their roles of Dawn and Becky, respectively. They had great stage presence and brought a lot of humor to the show. As Earl, Nick Bailey actually reminded me of Adam Pascal. Or at least his voice did. I liked him more in the role than I liked Jeremy Sisto in the movie. Jeremy Morse was hilarious as Ogie. He reminded me of a very young version of Leslie Jordan. I saw that he originated the role on Broadway. Finally, Maiesha McQueen was really funny as Nurse Norma.
It's been such a long time since I've seen the movie that I forgot Becky and Dawn even had their own story lines. Unless they were embellished for the stage production. I really need to watch the movie again. Just seeing the trailer again made me realize how similar the lines were. The one about coffee definitely stood out.
Overall, it was truly an enjoyable production. I got teary-eyed at the beginning and full-on cried at the end. I also laughed throughout, although not as much as I did for Something Rotten. The humor was more subtle. If you're able to see it in DC, it's here through Sunday and available on Today Tix. Otherwise, I hope you get to see it in a town near you, or on Broadway. It's definitely a treat. I'd suggest not bringing young children, as there are some inappropriate bits! I didn't even want to bring my Broadway loving 12 year-old to this one, and I'm glad for it.
Here is a glimpse of the show, featuring Sara Bareilles on Broadway:
I love the Playbill for this show. It captures the essence so well:
![]() |
| Saw it with my husband, who enjoyed it too |
![]() |
| Met up with one of my close friends (and theater buddies) there |







